Data platform

Apache Kafka or a replication platform: which one does your project need?

Apache Kafka is an event backbone for many consumers; a replication platform keeps databases in sync. Many projects need only the second.

  • Built and supported by Interkey An Interkey product, delivered and supported by Interkey
  • One platform for migration and continuous sync The move and the replication that follows it
  • No development team needed on your side Set up by configuration, run with the Interkey team

Apache Kafka is open-source software for streaming events between many systems, and it needs a team to build the connectors and operate the cluster. A replication platform such as iblync reads changes from one database and applies them to another through configuration. If the goal is migration or sync between databases, a replication platform is usually enough. If many applications must react to the same events, Kafka fits, and some estates run both.

Two different jobs

Apache Kafka and a replication platform often come up in the same conversation, but they do different jobs. Kafka is an event streaming platform: applications write events to it, it keeps them in order for a set period, and many other applications read the same events, each at its own pace. Its value grows with the number of systems that need to react to what happens elsewhere.

Read more

A replication platform has a narrower job. It reads the data and the changes in one database and applies them to another, so the two stay the same. It serves a migration, where the old system is switched off once the new one matches it, or continuous sync between systems that both stay in use. If your question is how to move the data of two or three databases, or keep them in step, you are asking the second question, not the first.

The two paths in one view

Two data paths: a replication platform between databases, and Apache Kafka between the systems that produce events and many consumers
PathWhere the data startsWhat carries itWhere it arrives
ReplicationOne databaseA replication platformAnother database, kept the same as the first
Event streamingA database or an application that produces eventsApache KafkaMany consumers, each reading the same events

The first path ends at a database that must match its source. The second ends at many applications, each acting on the same events in its own way.

What you build and what you run

The same six questions, asked of each option.

Three ways to move data: building on Apache Kafka, a managed streaming service, and a replication platform
QuestionSelf-built on Apache KafkaA managed streaming serviceA replication platform such as iblync
PurposeAn event backbone that many applications write to and read fromThe same backbone, with the cluster run by the service providerMigration and continuous sync between databases
Who builds the connectorsYour team, with Kafka Connect or its own codeYour team; some services offer ready connectors for certain systemsThe platform: iblync is set up by configuration, and custom connectors are built when needed
Who runs itYour team: the servers, their storage, upgrades and monitoringThe provider runs the cluster; your team runs topics, connectors and applicationsWith iblync, the Interkey team that operates it, with your team
Skills neededDistributed systems, Kafka operations, and programming for the applications that produce and consume eventsKafka design: topics, partitions, schemas and consumer codeKnowledge of your databases and data; no development team needed on your side with iblync
ReportsKafka reports on its own health; proof that a target matches its source has to be builtAs for self-builtWith iblync, weekly and monthly replication reports
When it fitsMany consumers, event replay and a platform team already in placeAn event backbone without running the cluster yourselvesMoving or syncing data between a few databases

What this table says about Apache Kafka is general and follows the project's public documentation. For how changes are read from a database in the first place, see our change data capture guide.

Signs you need an event backbone

If most of these describe your project, Apache Kafka, self-built or as a managed service, is likely the right foundation.

  • Many consumers need the same event: billing, notifications and analytics all react to one order.
  • Consumers must be able to replay events: a new application reads the history from the start, or a faulty one reads it again after a fix.
  • Several teams will build on the same stream, each with its own applications.
  • Many events do not come from a database at all: clicks, sensor readings, messages between services.
  • A platform team already runs the cluster, its upgrades and its monitoring, or is ready to. Our page on Kafka monitoring with Datadog covers the monitoring part.

Signs a replication platform is enough

If these describe your project more closely, building on Kafka adds work you do not need.

  • The data moves between two databases, or a small number of them.
  • The project is a migration: copy, keep in sync, switch, then retire the old system.
  • You have no development team free to build and maintain pipelines. See data replication without a development team.
  • Someone has to show, regularly, that the target matches the source.
  • The date is close, and there is no time to stand up and staff a new platform first.

Using both

Many estates need both jobs done. Apache Kafka works as the bridge between systems: it carries events from the applications that produce them to the many applications that react to them, and it is the cluster your own team runs. It is not a source or a target in the replication sense.

Moving a database to a new engine, or keeping two databases in step, is a different job with a different owner. Keeping the two jobs apart keeps each one simple: the event backbone serves the applications, and the replication platform serves the databases. If your estate already runs Kafka, say so in the form: the design of a replication project starts from the systems you already have.

What iblync adds

iblync is Interkey's platform for migration and continuous sync between different systems.

01

No development team needed on your side

iblync is set up through low-code workflows instead of per-project scripts, and it is delivered with the Interkey team that operates it.

02

Load control and a queue

Transfer speed and resource use can be limited on the source. If the target stops, changes wait in a queue and are applied when it returns.

03

Weekly and monthly reports

A detailed report of each transfer, with proof that it completed and that the old and new systems match. More on replication reports.

Scope

What this page covers

Interkey does not sell Apache Kafka, and running a Kafka cluster is not part of the iblync offer unless agreed separately. Apache Kafka is open-source software from the Apache Software Foundation; what this page says about it is general and follows its public documentation.

Questions about Apache Kafka and replication platforms

Is iblync a replacement for Apache Kafka?

Not as a general rule, because the two do different jobs. For migration or sync between databases, a replication platform such as iblync means you do not have to build that path on Kafka. For streaming events to many consumers, Kafka is the right tool, and it stays the bridge between systems that your team runs.

Do we need Kafka to keep two databases in sync?

Not necessarily. A replication platform reads the changes in the source database and applies them to the target directly, with no event backbone in between. Kafka earns its place when many other applications also need those changes. Our change data capture guide explains how changes are read from a database.

When is Apache Kafka the right choice?

When many applications must react to the same events, when consumers need to replay the history, when events come from applications as well as databases, and when a team is in place to run the cluster. In an estate like that, Kafka is the backbone, and a replication platform does not take its place.

What does running Kafka ourselves require?

A team that builds and maintains the connectors, designs topics and partitions, runs the servers and their storage, plans upgrades and watches the cluster day and night. The Apache Kafka documentation covers each of these tasks. The effort pays off when the backbone serves many applications, not two databases.

What about managed streaming services?

A managed streaming service runs the cluster for you, which removes the work on servers, storage and upgrades. Designing topics, building or configuring connectors and writing the applications that use the events stay with your team. It suits a team that needs an event backbone but not the work of running one.

Which option costs less?

This page does not compare figures, and the price of iblync is discussed in a meeting, followed by a written quote: see how iblync pricing works.

Next step

Ask an engineer one question

Tell us the systems your data moves between and who uses it at the other end. Ask one question about the choice in front of you.

Required field

By sending this form, you agree to our Privacy Notice.

What happens next

  1. We read your request
  2. An engineer contacts you
  3. You get an estimate or a demo

Or directly

+966-11-2180999 [email protected]

Tawuniya Towers, North Tower, 7th Floor, King Fahad Highway, Olaya, P.O. Box 56835, Riyadh 11564, Saudi Arabia

or See the systems iblync connects

Published by Interkey. Last updated . Interkey is registered in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia under commercial registration 1010156897.